Down markets are a chance to reassess and position ourselves for when things get better.
Research Analyst Matt Clark and I show you how you can do that with your income portfolio in today’s Investing With Charles.
We pit dividend stocks against bonds and show you how much further $10,000 will go invested in an American stalwart like Johnson & Johnson (NYSE: JNJ) compared to one of the most popular government bonds.
Let’s get into it.
Stocks vs. Bonds: What’s Better for Income?
Matt: Let’s jump right into it, Charles. I have a question here. This is from George. George asks:
If you’re looking for income in the market, which is better stocks or bonds?
Charles: The answer is stocks.
Now, let me preface that. Bonds are safer in the sense that a company has to pay its bond interest before it pays its dividend. That’s not optional. A company reserves the right to cut its dividend. But it can’t cut its bond payment without defaulting and winding up in bankruptcy court.
Bonds are safer in the sense that the bondholder gets paid first. But that’s less of a concern for a strong and healthy company.
If you’re diversifying, if you’re spreading your bets across multiple healthy companies, then even if one of them does fall on hard times, you’re covered. With that as an introduction: Yes, dividend stocks are a superior income source compared to bonds in most cases.
Healthy Dividend Stocks: Capital Gains + Quarterly Income
Matt: Now, we can do a little bit of a comparison here between a well-known dividend stock and a popular government bond.
Charles: We chose this stock because it is known to be somewhat stodgy and conservative. It sells Band-Aids, for crying out loud.
This company has been around forever. It’s a very stable, conservative and boring stock, making it somewhat bond-like, if you will.
Matt: The stock we have today is Johnson & Johnson (NYSE: JNJ).
First, we plugged things into an investment calculator using three factors:
- The current stock price.
- The amount of money and number of years that you’re going to hold.
- The expected dividend yield at present.
In this example, we used:
- JNJ’s stock price at the time of recording: $178.
- We started with $10,000 invested for 10 years.
- Expected dividend yield is about 2.4% distributed quarterly.
We did this over 10 years because the most common Treasury bond is a 10-year bond. That’s the one that’s most talked about.
I calculated averages, in terms of the average dividend increase and the average stock price increase, and I used 5% for both of those. That’s what we expect, according to historical trends.
Charles: That’s roughly in line with the long-term averages. It doesn’t mean that over every 10-year period the stock’s going to rise exactly 5% per year. It never works out quite like that.
Matt: Exactly. Using all those parameters, your $10,000 would grow to about $16,288 as a total investment after 10 years. That’s a total return of about 62%.
JNJ’s Healthy Gains
Matt: There’s always a but.
Charles: That’s assuming that you’ve been taking those dividends along the way as income. Remember, we’re doing this as an income example.
Every quarter it pays that dividend, you sweep that into your bank account for spending money.
That’s a 60% gain in one of the most conservative stocks in the market, while also collecting income and not reinvesting it.
Matt: If you used a dividend reinvestment plan (DRIP) to put those quarterly payouts back into your position, your total return would look more like 112%!
Dividend Income or Reinvest?
Charles: Yeah, and why would you reinvest those dividends?
Let’s say you’re not in retirement yet. You’re getting the pieces in place.
Reinvesting those dividends, what does that do?
It gets you more shares. Every time you get that dividend, that’s put into more shares, which then gives you a bigger base to collect more dividends, which gives you a bigger base for even more dividends. It gets that compounding working for you.
That’s great, but it depends on what you want to do.
If you’re working toward retirement and you’re still looking to grow the capital base, DRIPing is a fantastic idea. If you’re already in retirement and you need spending money, just take the dividends in cash.
What About Bonds?
Matt: Now, if we switch gears and look at a 10-year Treasury note and use the same $10,000 over 10 years… I know that yield right now (around 3%) is one thing, but we’ll use an average of about 2% for the expected interest rate.
If we do that, and you look at it on a semiannual payout basis over 10 years, you’re looking at a return of about $11,600 after 10 years. That’s a 20% return after taxes.
Charles: Also, there’s no capital appreciation. That’s just the income part. That’s a key part. You’re getting, let’s call it, a comparable amount of income with the JNJ stock and that Treasury note. It’s not going to be the same, but it’s in the same ballpark. That same amount’s going to hit your account every year.
The difference being that the Treasury note is not going to appreciate in value if you hold it to maturity. You get it at par. If you bought it at $1,000 par, it’s going to cash out at $1,000 par at the end of its life. There’s no room for capital appreciation.
Whereas, with the JNJ stock, if the future looks anything like the past, that stock will be worth considerably more in 10 years, 20 years, 30 years, infinity years than it is today.
Matt: The bottom line here is that in most cases, dividend-paying stocks are the way to go for income.
Charles: Again, to repeat why…
Let’s say you’re starting at a comparable income amount. If it’s a healthy company, its dividends should rise over time so that the payout gets a little bit higher every year. Then the icing on the cake is capital appreciation. At the end of the day, who doesn’t want capital appreciation?
A Tax Bonus for Dividend Stocks
Charles: One somewhat overlooked element is taxes.
If you’re holding all this stuff in an IRA or 401(k), it doesn’t necessarily matter. But if you’re doing this in a taxable portfolio, dividends are taxed at a preferential rate. Depending on your tax bracket, it’s either 0%, 15% or 20%.
Now, bond interest is taxed at your marginal rate. If you’re a high-income earner, you’re getting hosed there. You could be paying well over 30% of your interest earnings there.
By the way, bond yields are fairly meager to start with. We’re only talking about 2% yield, and you’re potentially giving well over 30% of that away in taxes if you’re in a high bracket.
Next Week: Asset Allocation
Matt: Next week, we want to talk about asset allocation, which has a direct correlation here.
What kind of assets should you hold in your portfolio under different circumstances? Right now, we’re looking at a market that is very much in flux, so what should your portfolio look like?
Charles: This is one of those fundamental, basic concepts in finance, but it’s also one of the most important. It’s also misunderstood.
Matt: Very much so.
Charles: This will be an important one.
Where to Find Us
Don’t forget to check out our Ask Adam Anything video series, where Chief Investment Strategist Adam O’Dell answers your questions.
You can also catch Matt every week on his Marijuana Market Update. If you are into cannabis investing, you don’t want to miss his weekly insights.
Remember, you can email my team and me at Feedback@MoneyandMarkets.com — or leave a comment on YouTube. We love to hear from you! We may even feature your question or comment in a future edition of Investing With Charles.
To safe profits,
Charles Sizemore, Co-Editor, Green Zone Fortunes
Charles Sizemore is the co-editor of Green Zone Fortunes and specializes in income and retirement topics. He is also a frequent guest on CNBC, Bloomberg and Fox Business.